Sunday’s Idols SA live show was a nod to a uniquely South African music genre as the contestants shared the stage with South Africa’s most celebrated DJs, fronting some of their greatest Amapiano hits.
Despite the disappointing news that Idols SA top 10 contestant Ithana had to leave the competition due to health reasons, the remaining Idols contestants had Mzansi grooving as they performed to show that they are the real deal.
But for their best efforts, judge Randall Abrahams was underwhelmed by most of the performances, saying contestants like Bulelani, Daylin Sass and Monique seemed like they were performing in a school concert, while he said others, like S’22Kile and Berry, tended to over-sing.
However, fellow judge Unathi Nkayi did not agree with him on some of the performers, saying Bulelani’s collaboration with DJ Sumbody was a great start for a challenging theme.
“I have nothing to critique you on negatively,” she said after Bulelani’s rendition of ‘Iyamemeza’. On Monique’s performance of Prince Kaybee’s ‘Charlotte’, originally sang by Lady Zamar, Unathi said she loved how dynamic the performance was. “You made it yours without taking away from the original.”
And while Randall commended Nqobie’s performance of Sun-El Musician’s ‘Akanamali’, Unathi felt the DJ has commanded more attention.
Likewise, there were standout performances that both Randall and Unathi agreed on. Both judges were impressed with Siya Mzizi, who sang ‘Emlanjeni’, accompanied by De Mthuda. “You inhabited the song,” Randall said, with Unathi saying the performance was brilliant. Kevin’s collaboration with DJ Sumbody was also received positively. His rendition of ‘Piki Piki’ ticked all the right boxes, with Randall saying he was doing all the right things to win votes and Unathi calling him a dream to watch.
Closing off the show on a high note, Karabo had the judges united as they both agreed she done justice to DJ Cleo’s ‘Gcina Mpilo Yami’.
With the performances in the bag, it will soon be up to the viewers to decide who should advance to the next stage of the competition.